For years, Florida families paid a “tort tax” and had no idea. This came from higher premiums driven by a legal system that rewarded lawsuits over solutions. By the Florida Chamber’s count, the state had about 8 percent of the nation’s homeowners’ claims but roughly 76 percent of its homeowners’ insurance lawsuits. By 2023, insurance was out of control, to the extent that the state’s largest auto insurers were filing average rate increases of 31.7 percent.
Then came HB 837. Signed March 24, 2023, it ended one-way attorney fees in insurance cases, tightened the bad-faith standard, cut the negligence statute of limitations from four years to two, and made juries look at what medical care actually cost. It reformed a system that allowed opportunists to profit while we paid the costs.
The numbers since tell the story: Florida’s five largest auto insurers filed an average 7.4 percent decrease for 2025 and are indicating another 8 percent cut for 2026. Insurance Commissioner Mike Yaworsky says nearly 80 percent of Florida auto policyholders are seeing lower rates this year. Florida’s personal auto liability loss ratio hit 52.5 percent in 2025, the lowest in the nation. State Farm has cut rates more than 20 percent since fall 2024, and Progressive reported nearly $1 billion in credits to policyholders. These big changes make a big difference to the bottom lines of working families.
The best part is that property insurance is following. Citizens cut rates for the first time since 2015, 17 new insurers have entered the market, and 48 companies have filed for decreases since January 2024. An industry-commissioned actuarial study found Floridians paid nearly $3 billion less for home and auto insurance in 2025 than the year before.
The results haven’t stopped just this month; regulators approved an average 12.8 percent cut on roughly 120,000 renters policies. We all experienced the reality of knowing somebody, if it wasn’t ourselves, that lost coverage overnight, and thankfully those times are now in the rearview mirror.
Yet despite these successes, the American Tort Reform Association has put the Florida Legislature on a “watch list” over repeated efforts to repeal parts of the 2023 reforms. There were even bills filed in 2025 that would have made our justice system a money-making machine again for attorneys. Thankfully, the reforms survived but the push to undo them have not stopped.
So, what has changed? Perhaps contributions from trial lawyers to political campaigns have increased. Regardless, rolling back reform would invite back the lawsuit surge that drove rates up and families would pay for it at every renewal. Lawmakers should build on what is working.
Close the loopholes that still let lawsuit abuse inflate costs and keep pressure on carriers to pass savings through. Florida now has a proven blueprint that has delivered results, blowing this opportunity would hurt us all
Henry John Munoz
Ocala, Florida
