Florida Insurance Commissioner Mike Yaworsky announced three auto insurers will return $122.6 million in excess profits back to eligible Florida policyholders in time for the holiday season through a release this week.
According to Commissioner Yaworsky, Cimarron Insurance, Inc., Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company and Security National Insurance Company will give back policy renewals or credits within 60 days from calendar and accident years between 2023-2025.
“Happy to announce Floridians who have auto insurance with Cimarron, Liberty Mutual or Security National will be receiving refund checks this holiday season," Yaworsky said. "The Office of Insurance Regulation keeps an open dialogue with auto insurers about excess profits, and I encourage other companies to review their books too. I am grateful for these companies’ cooperation to provide data to our office quickly and acting in the best interest of consumers.”
Specifically, Cimarron will return $908,149 to applicable policyholders, Liberty Mutual will return $73,139,740, and Security National will return $48,628,580. The returns bring the total excess profits policyholder refunds to over $168 million in 2026 alone.
Florida law requires insurers to return excess profits if underwriting gains for the three most recent calendar-accident years combined surpass the anticipated underwriting profit plus five percent of earned premiums over that period.
“Once again, Florida’s insurance carriers are able to return money to the policyholders, demonstrating that Florida’s historic tort reforms are working for their intended purpose to strengthen Florida’s insurance market," Florida Chief Financial Officer (CFO) Blaise Ingoglia added. "Ensuring that the insurance market is working for the policyholders is my top priority and I will continue to work with the Office of Insurance Regulation to make more announcements like this.”
Helping Floridians, CFO Ingoglia and Commissioner Yaworsky also announced insurance rate decreases for over 800,000 state homeowners last month.
Yaworsky has been Florida's Insurance Commissioner (not including interim) since March 2023, while Ingoglia has been chief financial officer since July 2025.
